Kritikon ki Rai (Critical Reviews)
-
Times of India ke Dhaval Roy ke mutaabiq, "Saiyaara is a visually lush, emotive, and melody-driven experience… Impressive leads, heartfelt romance and emotions, and melodic tracks make it a worthwhile one-time watch" The Times of India.
-
Hindustan Times ne likha: "Overall, Saiyaara may not break new ground in terms of storytelling, but it strikes the right emotional chords… Ahaan and Aneet share convincing chemistry" Hindustan Times.
-
Rotten Tomatoes aur Gulf News jaise outlets isey "glossy, well-meaning attempt at heartbreak cinema — but it never quite breaks through" kehkar rate karte hain, aur "sentimental Bollywood romance lovers may enjoy it, despite shallow character development" ki tipanni bhi ki hai Rotten Tomatoes.
-
Sucharita Tyagi (Medium) ka vishleshan thoda aalochak hai: "high-intensity melodrama throughout, with little room for reflection… lacks emotional layering in its soundtrack beyond the title track" Medium.
-
High On Films ne maana: "Not groundbreaking, but has a beating heart… fresh-faced chemistry, but overly dramatic screenplay and messy storytelling" High On Films.
Audience aur Reddit Par Vichaar
-
Rotten Tomatoes par audience ka tanaazur varied hai — koi kehta hai “Very emotional, I cried”, toh koi likhta hai “Waste of time, no depth” Rotten Tomatoes.
-
Reddit (r/bollywoodmemes) par kuch log films ko criticize kar rahe hain:
“This movie is shit. Wasted 2.5 hours… No real storyline... Songs are mediocre” Reddit.
-
Ek aur user bolta hai:
“Movie is decent. The actors were competent. It’s simple story, good screenplay + cinematography and GREAT music…” Reddit.
-
Ek heartfelt fan review mein:
“Music is the strongest part… Ahaan has great potential… Aneet Padda was great… Overall very simple and good. Must watch at least once.” Reddit.
Summary: Saiyaara Kaisi Film Hai?
Positives:
-
Strong chemistry between Ahaan Panday aur Aneet Padda.
-
Melodic music aur soulful tracks jo kaafi log ko pasand aaye.
-
Visual storytelling aur direction (Mohit Suri) ka cinematic appeal bahaal.
Negatives:
-
Predictable plot aur clichés ka feel: familiar formula and formulaic storytelling.
-
Over-melodramatic pacing, emotional highs har scene mein—kabhi aram-se absorb karna mushkil.
-
Music beyond title track mein emotional depth missing; background score bhi ek-pan hi raheta hai.
Final Verdict
"Saiyaara" ek aisi romantic musical drama hai jo emotions, music aur cinematic visuals ko barhawa deta hai. Agar aap emotional Bollywood romances pasand karte hain — especially jo nostalgia ya love-ballad style rakhte ho — toh isse ek baar zaroor dekha jaa sakta hai.
Watch Full Movie 👇 Clik Here
0 Comments